Volunteers or Slaves? Brazil's Use of Cheap Prison Labor - FreedomUnited.org

Volunteers or Slaves? Brazil’s Use of Cheap Prison Labor

  • Published on
    April 11, 2019
  • Written by:
    Jamison Liang
  • Category:
    Forced Labor
Hero Banner

Rio de Janeiro is using prisoners as “volunteer workers” in order to maintain jails, with inmates cooking, cleaning, and performing maintenance.

This system of using prisoners as cheap laborers has long existed in Brazil’s under-funded jails, and prisoners return a small allowance and reduced sentences for their work.

Take Action: Help Stop Forced Labor of Detainees

However, last July Rio de Janeiro introduced a new category of work called “volunteer labor” — a highly controversial move as federal and state laws requires inmates to be paid for all work done in jail.

Thomson Reuters Foundation reports:

The resolution was authorised by state judge Rafael Estrela, who told the Thomson Reuters Foundation that prison authorities had insisted they had no money for wages and, without his authorisation, the entire jail system risked collapse.

Brazil’s jail population has surged eight-fold in three decades to about 750,000 inmates, the world’s third highest tally, with authorities saying another 350,000 spaces are needed in the nation’s 1,500 jails.

The emergency labour measure was supposed to end in January but on Feb. 25, the judge extended it for another 180 days.

Estrela denied the change amounted to endorsing slavery as the inmates were volunteers but said he was “uncomfortable” with his decision, feeling he had no choice.

“Everything would stop … trash would go uncollected, food would not be delivered, various repairs in the electrical and hydraulic grid would stop being made. It would be complete chaos.”

Still, human rights campaigners and the UN say this new system is illegal.

Instituto Igarape, a non-profit that focuses on public safety issues, estimates that around 420 inmates are being made to take care of the jails for free.

“It is our understanding that the state put inmates in a situation analogous to slavery,” added Natalia Damazio, a member of the State Mechanism for the Prevention and Fight Against Torture, which documents human rights violations in detention centers.

Estrela maintains that there is nothing he can do to avert the crisis.

“The people who criticise this decision, what solution do they have? There are none,” he said. “When you have a problem like this, you look for other solutions … Then tomorrow a prison riot breaks out, with deaths … and it’s on me.”

Freedom United is interested in hearing from our community and welcomes relevant, informed comments, advice, and insights that advance the conversation around our campaigns and advocacy. We value inclusivity and respect within our community. To be approved, your comments should be civil.

stop icon A few things we do not tolerate: comments that promote discrimination, prejudice, racism, or xenophobia, as well as personal attacks or profanity. We screen submissions in order to create a space where the entire Freedom United community feels safe to express and exchange thoughtful opinions.

1 Comment
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Regina Bianco
Regina Bianco
4 years ago

Please, don’t judge what is not known.It is important that these people work,have activities,instead of doing nothing ,form gangs inside prison.Their cost is high and their mantenence is also their responsibility.

This week

Four years on, has Australia's Modern Slavery Act been effective?

An independent review of Australia's Modern Slavery Act has concluded that the legislation is failing to have a significant impact on curbing modern slavery and urges the Australian government to implement recommendations to strengthen the law. The Australian government must act According to the latest Global Slavery Index released by international human rights organization Walk Free, an estimated 50 million people were in situations of modern slavery

| Wednesday May 31, 2023

Read more