Kuwaiti beauty blogger Sondos Alqattan received a firestorm of criticism for complaining that Filipino domestic workers did not deserve the right to keep their passports or a day off each week. Anti-slavery campaigners around the world quickly condemned her remarks, and several major beauty companies severed ties with the Instagram star.
But Alqattan’s attitude towards migrants isn’t rare. Across the Gulf, many employers view migrant domestic workers — largely women from Africa and Asia — as their property, servants who do not deserve the right to step outside or even rest.
Related Campaign: Help end domestic slavery.
As Laura Secorun from the ILO writes in The New York Times, this sense of entitlement stems from the kafala system present in many Middle Eastern states:
Better laws can reduce forced labor, but they will not end it. For starters, throughout much of the Arab world, such regulations operate within a much larger, inherently exploitative structure — the “kafala” system. This form of visa sponsorship is believed to have originated in Gulf states to accommodate foreign workers, mostly from South Asian countries like Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh.
Over the years, the scheme has evolved from helping protect migrants to severely limiting domestic workers’ rights. Under today’s kafala, a migrant is not allowed to leave her employer without the employer’s consent. She is also forbidden from changing employers or traveling out of the country.
Escaping is a crime, punishable by arrest and deportation. Human Rights Watch has long argued that no secondary regulation can guarantee the safety of domestic workers as long as the kafala keeps them legally handcuffed to their employers.
Secorun further points out that labor rules in many Gulf states are determined through bilateral agreements with ‘sending’ countries rather than a general labor law. As a result, labor protections depend heavily on which country a migrant hails from and what their government has agreed to.
“That is why, toward the end of her tirade on Kuwait’s labor regulations, Alqattan said, “I will no longer have a Filipino maid.” In other words, she could just hire someone from a country governed by weaker labor protections. Same abuse, different victim,” explains Secorun.
“If we truly want to eradicate forced domestic labor, we must confront the rampant prejudice behind it. What we need are programs that help employers see their homes as workplaces and migrant women as professionals, worthy of fair pay and safe working conditions,” concludes Secorun.
Photo credit: Moises Saman/Magnum Photos / The New York Times
Freedom United is interested in hearing from our community and welcomes relevant, informed comments, advice, and insights that advance the conversation around our campaigns and advocacy. We value inclusivity and respect within our community. To be approved, your comments should be civil.
A few things we do not tolerate: comments that promote discrimination, prejudice, racism, or xenophobia, as well as personal attacks or profanity. We screen submissions in order to create a space where the entire Freedom United community feels safe to express and exchange thoughtful opinions.
If the problem is the “kafala” system that operates in some Arab states then the answer to people with the mindset of Sondos Alqattan is the disolvement of this cruel system ,or for all the foreign workers withdrawing their job searches from these states, after all if you are working 20+ hours a day for little food or comfort and low or no pay then what is the attraction in that, then this slave owner would have to do the work herself wouldn’t she?
Horrible practice, all foreign govts , from the countries that domestic workers originate, must insist on humane laws based on Universal Human Rights, by the employing Arab nations.. Passports must be with the domestic workers/or their consulates/embassies and Not with the Owners, who exploit and ill treat them.
Some of the richest people in Dubai are Pakistanis
The whole Dubai marina area has Pakistani properties investing in $158 billion dollars