Should Child Sex Trafficking Victims Face Jail for Killing Their Abusers?

2
Child SlaveryLaw & Policy

Cyntoia Brown’s case made national headlines following a national outcry over the child sex trafficking survivor’s life sentencing for killing a man who solicited her for sex when she was 16.

The public pressure led to former-Tennessee Gov. Bill Haslam granting her clemency earlier this year.

Take Action: End Criminalization of Child Sex Trafficking Victims

And now the movement for decriminalizing child sex trafficking victims is growing: Congress and three states are now tabling legislation that would change how courts treat juvenile sex trafficking victims tried as adults for committing crimes against their abusers.

Mother Jones reports:

The bills in Nevada, Arkansas, Hawaii, and Congress, which are based on model legislation and use similar language, would do away with mandatory minimum sentencing requirements for child sex trafficking victims who perpetrate crimes against their abusers.

Currently, state and federal laws don’t give special consideration to such cases, meaning juvenile victims who commit the most serious crimes, like murder, are often tried in adult court with the possibility of decades behind bars.

The federal legislation, introduced by Republican Rep. Bruce Westerman of Arkansas in March, is part of a package of bills that seek to reform the juvenile justice system. The other two bills in the package would also ban life without parole for minors and limit the use of mandatory minimums for all juvenile offenders, not just victims of sex trafficking.

The legislation “recognizes that girls and boys trapped in sex trafficking may resort to violence to escape,” Westerman said in a statement announcing the federal bill. “The goal of the justice system should be to reform and rehabilitate young people that have committed crimes, not to lock them up and throw away the key.”

A growing body of research shows that trauma from sex trafficking affects the decision making of victims, especially children. The desire to escape their abuse, combined with impulsivity, can prompt trafficking victims to act without considering legal consequences.

Unfortunately, it looks like only Nevada’s legislation will succeed this session; it passed in the Assembly last month and is expected to pass in the Senate before early June. Arkansas and Hawaii both failed to get the bill passed before their legislative sessions ended, and the federal bill is stalled in committee.

Chip in and help end modern slavery once and for all.

2
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
avatar
500
2 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
4 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
2 Comment authors
Angelo FornaroMaureen Henderson Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Angelo Fornaro
Guest
Angelo Fornaro

No.. Non dovrebbero fare neanche un giorno le vittime di abuso .

Maureen Henderson
Guest

No , no penalty for a trafficked person killing the trafficker. They’d be doing the world a favour.