Photo credit: Lacy Atkins/The Tennessean/USA TODAY NETWORK

Calls for Clemency as Cyntoia Brown Given 51 Years in Jail

Human TraffickingLaw & PolicyRehabilitation & LiberationSurvivor Stories

Despite being a victim of sex trafficking, the Tennessee Supreme Court has ruled that Cyntoia Brown must spend 51 years behind bars for killing a man who tried to have sex with her, fearing he was going to kill her.

The ruling has sparked outrage, with many of Brown’s supporters now calling on Tennessee Governor Bill Haslam to grant a pardon.

The Women’s March announced that it would dedicate January’s protest to Cyntoia “and all those criminalized for surviving.” The group tweeted “Gov. Haslam has the power to #FreeCyntoia.”

“Every day she remains in prison, he is actively choosing not to.”

Governing Magazine reports:

In 2004, 16-year-old Brown was picked up on the side of the road by Nashville real estate agent Johnny Allen, 43, who took her home for sex. The teenage girl, who had run away from home and was living with her 24-year-old boyfriend, a pimp who went by “Kut Throat,” fatally shot Allen in bed after she thought he was reaching for his own gun, her lawyers said.

Brown was tried as an adult, convicted of first-degree murder, felony murder and aggravated robbery and was sentenced to life in prison.

Tennessee laws have changed since Brown was convicted, though, and a person must be 18 or older to be charged for prostitution. Children are automatically considered the victim in sex trafficking cases.

Brown has called her life sentencing “cruel and unusual punishment,” citing a 2012 Supreme Court ruling that mandatory life sentences for juveniles without the possibility of parole are unconstitutional.

However, the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee disagreed, arguing that the 2012 decision did not apply to Brown because she is not eligible for parole until she is age 69.

A number of celebrities, including Rihanna and Kim Kardashian, have condemned how Brown has been treated like a criminal when she is in fact a victim of human trafficking.

“The system has failed,” tweeted Kardashian in Nov. 2017, adding “Free Cyntoia Brown.”

Chip in and help end modern slavery once and for all.

Leave a Reply

50 Comment threads
22 Thread replies
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
58 Comment authors
Miguel Angel LeraBeryl AckermannProfessor Emeritus Ferrel ChristensenJerry McGeeWendy Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Miguel Angel Lera
Miguel Angel Lera

Todo tiene su origen en el erroneo manejo que tenemos los seres humanos y erroneos conceptos sobre el sexo.

Beryl Ackermann
Beryl Ackermann

This is heartbreaking. What does a sixteen year old girl know. They are so many young girl taken in under false pretenses and groomed, put on drugs, threatened and put the “fear’ in them, to do as they are told. Yet when these yiung children report it. NO ONE will believe them, but believe these “evil” people who ruin their lives. What if it was one of their “own daughters”. Justice will come to these “evil” perverts who ruin the lives of many young boys and girls. Sick, “evil” minded society.

Professor Emeritus Ferrel Christensen
Professor Emeritus Ferrel Christensen

A very different account is told here: (If she could access and use a gun on the spur of the moment, why had she not already killed her trafficker?–Just one of several questions the court’s account raises re her claim to having been a trafficking victim.) Freedom United must not lose its credibility by adopting the noxious “always believe the woman” ideology–the fate of genuine victims would be put in even greater jeopardy.

Jerry McGee
Jerry McGee

She is the victim, what part of that does the judge not understand?

Grant Williams
Grant Williams

How can I help free this young woman? What is being done? Please….something else besides money. I am more distrustful these days when it comes to donations like this. I have Cyntoia’s address and will be writing her….