Police Wrongly Prosecute Slavery Victim - FreedomUnited.org

Police Wrongly Prosecute Slavery Victim

  • Published on
    October 1, 2018
  • Written by:
    Jamison Liang
  • Category:
    Forced Labor, Law & Policy, Rehabilitation & Liberation
Hero Banner

The police and Crown Prosecution Service have come under fire for attempting to prosecute a Vietnamese teenager who was likely trafficked to the UK and forced to grow cannabis.

A judge recently dismissed the case against the Vietnamese boy, saying that he is probably a victim of modern slavery, but he now faces deportation to Vietnam.

Related Campaign: Support for all UK modern slavery victims

An investigation by The Times in 2012 uncovered that more than 1,100 Vietnamese children had been trafficked to Britain for forced labor, but UK authorities arrested them instead of treating them as victims. The authorities have refused to reveal what happened to these children after they were put in detention, and the Crown Prosecution Service has no data on how many were prosecuted or convicted.

The Times reports:

Judge Robert Trevor-Jones dismissed the case against the boy, who said that he was 16, on the fourth day of his trial at Liverpool crown court. The child had spent six months in custody on remand. The boy, who does not speak English, had been accused of being involved in the production of cannabis. He was arrested at a cannabis farm in St Helens earlier this year.

Baroness Butler-Sloss, who helped to draft the Modern Slavery Bill in 2014, said that the case was “undoubtedly a waste of court time, the judge’s time and the jury’s time — as well as a waste of public money. If he is genuinely a victim, to deport him without protection will be to put him back in the hands of the traffickers.”

The court was told that the boy’s parents had died and he was responsible for their debts. He said he had been threatened by creditors who told him to earn money in the UK. He was taken to China, shipped to France, smuggled into England on a lorry and given to a man in Manchester known as Uncle.

Uncle took him to St Helens where he was told to help men to take bags and boxes into a flat above a newsagents. The boy denied knowing that these contained cannabis plants and thought that he was moving household goods. Judge Trevor-Jones asked if the defendant had been subject to a referral under the Modern Slavery Act and said that if the boy were convicted he would ask for one.

The prosecution admitted that they did not know if the boy had been directed to the National Referral Mechanism — the UK’s system for identifying victims of modern slavery.

In light of this, Judge Trevor-Jones said that it would be “wrong to risk a possible conviction.” He called for the Home Office to assess the boy’s status and verify his age.

Debbie Beadle from anti-trafficking NGO ECPAT UK, said deporting child trafficking victims would put them back into danger.

“Being wrongly accused of crime and put through the court system means child victims are at risk of being removed from the UK and placed back into a situation where they are vulnerable to being re-trafficked,” she said.

Freedom United is interested in hearing from our community and welcomes relevant, informed comments, advice, and insights that advance the conversation around our campaigns and advocacy. We value inclusivity and respect within our community. To be approved, your comments should be civil.

stop icon A few things we do not tolerate: comments that promote discrimination, prejudice, racism, or xenophobia, as well as personal attacks or profanity. We screen submissions in order to create a space where the entire Freedom United community feels safe to express and exchange thoughtful opinions.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

This week

Migrant workers jailed in Qatar over demands for owed wages

Five months on from the World Cup final, migrant workers continue to report exploitative labor practices and mistreatment at the hands of Qatari authorities. Three former security guards have been jailed in Qatar for four months following their repeated requests for unpaid wages from their employer, Stark Security Services. Though lauded by FIFA as an opportunity to improve Qatar’s treatment of migrant workers, workers who toiled to make the world’s

| Friday May 26, 2023

Read more