Texas flag

Border law leads to 53 dead in Texas tragedy

3
Law & Policy

53 people have now died from hyperthermia trapped in a sealed truck found in Texas, 160 miles from the U.S. Mexico border where outside temperatures reached 109F (39C) last week.

Of the dozen who survived the horrific conditions when the truck, near San Antonio, was finally opened on Monday morning after a worker heard cries for help, several have died in hospital.

The role of borders and restrictive immigration policies

It is suspected that the victims crossed into the U.S. using irregular migration routes. We now know that the victims were from Mexico, Honduras, Guatemala and El Salvador. This is the worst case of migrant deaths due to smuggling in the U.S.

Mexican President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador blamed poverty and trafficking. At a briefing he said: “It happens because there is trafficking of people and a lack of control, in this case at the Mexican-US border, but also in the US interior”.

However, we must be careful not to conflate trafficking and smuggling. To establish trafficking we must prove the act of recruiting, transporting etc by threat, deception, abduction for the purposes of exploitation. Smuggling is the unlawful movement of a person across borders for financial gain.

The most effective way to end smuggling is to provide safe routes of migration. This would both undermine smugglers’ business model, which relies on the lack of safe alternative options, and prevent future tragedies like this.

Emily Kenway writes on Open Democracy:

These deaths were predictable and preventable. They are the product of two factors: increasingly militarised borders and the continuing determination of people to cross those borders despite that militarisation. Just last month, the number of people apprehended crossing the border from Mexico into the USA surpassed previous records. Deaths are breaking records as well. At least 650 people died in 2021, the highest figure since records began. It’s clear that making borders harder to cross isn’t stopping people from trying. It’s only pushing them to take riskier routes, raising the risks of injury and death.

Why we need safe migration

Policies that make it hard for people to move, whether for a better life, to escape persecution, the effects of climate change or war, only encourage smuggling as people are forced into taking greater risks.

These risks led to death this week in Texas. For obvious reasons, we hear much less about the risks migrants face of being exploited for their labor or sexual abuse, as unscrupulous traffickers take advantage of the lack of safe options available.

That’s why Freedom United is calling for safe migration as an effective strategy to help prevent trafficking. With safe routes, people can migrate without being made vulnerable to criminals.

Chip in and help end modern slavery once and for all.

Freedom United is interested in hearing from our community and welcomes relevant, informed comments, advice, and insights that advance the conversation around our campaigns and advocacy. We value inclusivity and respect within our community. To be approved, your comments should be civil.

stop icon A few things we do not tolerate: comments that promote discrimination, prejudice, racism, or xenophobia, as well as personal attacks or profanity. We screen submissions in order to create a space where the entire Freedom United community feels safe to express and exchange thoughtful opinions.

guest
3 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Temple Cloud
1 month ago

This is something that my own country (United Kingdom) also needs to address, and I sign petitions to the British government calling for safe migration routes, as well. A friend of mine (in Britain) told me last week about a similar case in his work, of intercepting a lorry containing people exposed to extreme hunger, thirst, and cold.

Brian
Brian
1 month ago

Open borders are the only “safe” means because these people are still going to be scammed and/or coached on what to say or do to get past scrutiny that’s there to find people who really need to enter for safety reasons. Looking for a “better life” isn’t a valid reason to smuggle into the US, and it isn’t the government’s responsibility to make a “safe route” for illegals to enter the country.
Communities are built by members, they don’t want just anyone coming there to disrupt what they built.

rick
rick
25 days ago
Reply to  Brian

On 6 days of the week,long lines around the US Embassy
in Mexico lead to safe ways to emigrate.