Empower and protect: rethinking bans on child labor

2
Child Slavery

“Child labor isn’t going anywhere, so children’s safety in work must become the priority.”

Writing in Open Democracy, Edward Van Daalen and Mohammed Al-Rozzi argue that we should rethink bans on child labor. 2021 is the UN International Year for the Elimination of Child Labour — a goal that won’t be achieved — and child labor won’t be eliminated by 2025 as proposed in the UN Sustainable Development Goals.

While bans on child labor may sound good on paper and may reduce numbers in some areas, it also pushes child workers into the shadows. As part of a larger series for Beyond Trafficking and Slavery, the authors present alternatives to bans, chiefly the approach of ’empower and protect, rather than prohibit’.

As reported in Open Democracy:

Over the last three decades, international organisations like the International Labour Organization (ILO), UNICEF and the Global March Against Child Labour have carefully cultivated, mainstreamed, and transformed this one-dimensional narrative into support for the ‘total abolition’ of child labour. However, what legally and empirically lies behind the catch-all concept of ‘child labour’ is much more complex and nuanced than this narrow and sensationalist representation suggests.

One of the primary assumptions of this campaign is that work and education are mutually exclusive. Some abolitionists even go as far as to claim that a child who is not enrolled in school is de facto in child labour. However, even the ILO’s own figures on child labour refute this trope by showing that the vast majority of working children combine work and school. It is also widely acknowledged that work itself holds educational potential, and child advocates have argued repeatedly that formal enrolment in school is not a sufficient metric for capturing where, what, or how much children learn.

Another assumption is that work is intrinsically harmful to children’s health and morale. While some children certainly work under harmful conditions and steps should be taken to minimise this, the ILO’s global estimates suggest that most work done by children is not hazardous. And non-hazardous work can have beneficial effects on children’s psychological and professional development.

A third assumption is that children always work against their will. Yet working children have repeatedly told researchers that they undertake work for a variety of economic, cultural, social or emotional reasons. Moreover, these working children reject the label of being ‘slaves’ and instead say they want to be involved as active participants in research and policy-making that affect them.

With this in mind, the authors argue that an overarching goal of eliminating all forms of child labor is both unrealistic and not reflective of what working children want or need.

Given the evidence that child labor bans can exacerbate “precarious situations and those of their families and communities,” they conclude that “interventions and campaigns should be evidence-based, locally adapted, informed by working children’s own experiences, and should consider well-being holistically.”

Chip in and help end modern slavery once and for all.

Freedom United is interested in hearing from our community and welcomes relevant, informed comments, advice, and insights that advance the conversation around our campaigns and advocacy. We value inclusivity and respect within our community. To be approved, your comments should be civil.

stop icon A few things we do not tolerate: comments that promote discrimination, prejudice, racism, or xenophobia, as well as personal attacks or profanity. We screen submissions in order to create a space where the entire Freedom United community feels safe to express and exchange thoughtful opinions.

guest
2 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
John Blocher
John Blocher
4 days ago

There is some merit in thinking of study/work programs, whether formal or informal, as being a possibility. The problems start occurring when children are taken out of school to work or to work more than when they were in school. The damage occurs when it becomes just work rather than school plus work. Parents all over the world introduce children to some level of work in positive ways to make sure the child can eventually survive on their own.

Joseph P. Lapinski
Joseph P. Lapinski
5 days ago

A child does not, by definition, have an adult’s cognitive ability to decide what is good for them.
At what age is the brain fully developed?
Although brain development is subject to significant individual variation, most experts suggest that the brain is fully developed by age 25. For some people, brain development may be complete prior to age 25, while for others it may end after age 25. The mid-20s or “25” is just an average age given as checkpoint for when the brain has likely become mature